A short shipment is usually arithmetic, not a scandal. Cartons are packed to a plan, the plan is written onto a packing list, and the difference between that list and what actually arrives is the claim. What makes it expensive is not the missing units. It is that the evidence gets weaker every hour the cartons sit opened on a warehouse floor.
Three places the count goes wrong, and why they are not the same claim
Short-loaded at packing. The carton count is correct and the units per carton are not. Twelve cartons of twenty-four arrive as twelve cartons of twenty-two, and the pallet looks untouched. This is a factory-side error, systematic rather than random, and provable by weight.
Damaged in transit. The units arrived, but they are not sellable — crushed tubes, leaked bottles, labels lifted by moisture. The count on the invoice is right and the sellable count is not. This is a carrier-side claim, and it only stands if the damage was noted at handover or is visible in photographs taken before the pallet was broken down.
Documentation mismatch. The packing list, the commercial invoice and the physical shipment describe three different things. A SKU was substituted, a lot number was not updated, or the invoice was raised on the ordered quantity rather than the shipped quantity. Nothing is missing; until the paperwork reconciles, you do not know what to claim for.
The first twenty minutes decide the case
Do not move the pallet. Do not open every carton looking for the gap. Four photographs, taken in this order, are what a claim is built on:
- The whole pallet, shrink-wrap and seal intact, with the carrier’s label readable.
- The carton label, close enough that SKU, lot and carton number can be read.
- The opened carton from above, showing how the units were arranged and how much void was left inside.
- The damaged unit next to the carton it came out of, so the two can be tied together.
Then a written tally: cartons received, units per carton, units counted, units damaged. Photographs without a tally are anecdotes. A tally without photographs is an assertion. Both together are a claim.
Weigh the cartons before you count them
Counting two thousand units by hand takes an afternoon and produces an argument. Weighing twelve cartons takes ten minutes and produces a fact. If the packing list states a gross weight per carton and the average of what you received is below it by more than the packaging can explain, the shortage was loaded short — it did not disappear in transit. That distinction decides who pays.
This is also why the packing list should be built per carton rather than per shipment. A single line reading “2,000 units” cannot tell you which carton is short. A list reading carton 1 to 84, twenty-four units each, can. If your supplier does not issue one, ask for it before the deposit — it costs nothing at the factory and it is the difference between a claim and a complaint. The same discipline applies to how a private label run is documented from artwork approval onward, which is covered in our private label process.
Claim against the party who held the goods
Three parties can be responsible; usually only one is at fault. The factory is responsible for what was packed and for how it was packed. The forwarder or carrier is responsible from the moment it took custody, which is why a clean receipt signed at pickup is worth more than any later argument. Customs and the destination warehouse are responsible only for what their own inventory record shows, and only if the record was made at the time of receipt.
Send the notice in writing to the party in custody at the point of loss, within whatever window their terms state, and copy the other two. A notice sent to the factory about damage that happened after handover will be answered politely and closed. If you are unsure how a supplier normally handles this, the questions worth asking before the order are listed in our wholesale FAQ.
Settling without placing a second order
Replacement units are the cleanest outcome when the SKU is in production. A credit note against the next order is the most common, and it is only worth what the next order’s invoice says — a credit agreed in an email and not deducted later has a way of evaporating. A price adjustment on the following run works when the shortage is small.
What does not work is accepting a verbal promise to make it up next time. If the remedy is a credit, it belongs on the next purchase order as a line item with an amount and a reference to the original shipment. If it is replacement stock, it belongs on a proforma with a ship date.
Before you reorder
Reorder only after the cause is named. If the short-load came from a carton configuration that was changed without telling you — a different unit count per carton, a thinner inner box — then reordering the same quantity reproduces the same shortage. Fix the specification first, confirm it in writing, and adjust the order quantity upward only against a credit you have already received, not one you expect. Where the goods are made and packed is part of this picture, and our factory page sets out the production and inspection sequence a buyer can hold a supplier to.
Buyers who distribute rather than resell face one extra step: the shortage has to be recorded before stock is allocated to customers, or the loss is absorbed silently at the end of the quarter. The documentation a distributor is expected to keep is set out in our distributor programme.
Leave a Reply