Who Owns Packaging Artwork Approval: Brand, Factory or Printer?

Most packaging problems are not printing problems. They are approval problems: a file was approved by someone who was not authorised to approve it, a change was approved in a chat message, or a reprint was triggered by something nobody had classified as a change. This note sets out who approves artwork, what counts as a change, and where the cost of an error usually lands.

Artwork is not the mockup

The mockup is the image used to sell the idea. Artwork is the print file built on the supplier’s dieline: the exact shape of the tube, jar or carton, with bleed, safe margins, colour separation and the barcode placed where the scanner can read it. Approving a mockup and calling the artwork approved is the most common source of reprints, because a mockup does not carry bleed, does not show text at final size, and does not test whether the barcode scans.

Three approvals, not one

Each side signs a different question, and none of them can be skipped.

  • Brand approval — does the pack say what we intend, legally and commercially: product name, net quantity, ingredient list in the required order, batch and expiry coding, warnings, importer details.
  • Factory approval — can this actually be printed and applied: minimum type size, colour count, material compatibility, whether the label survives a filling line, whether the dieline matches the component currently in stock.
  • Printer approval — will this file reproduce as intended: trapping, overprint, Pantone versus process builds, and how the chosen substrate shifts the colour.

A single “approved” covering all three is how a legally complete file ends up printed in the wrong colour, or a beautiful file arrives with a barcode that will not scan.

One named signatory per side

Approval needs a person, not a committee. Name one signatory on the brand side and one on the supplier side in the purchase order, and accept approval only from those two addresses. A message from a colleague who is helpful but not named is not an approval, and in a dispute it will not be treated as one. Each approval should reference a version number and a date, and the approved file should be archived with the message that approved it.

What counts as a change

Reprints are usually caused by changes that were treated as small. Any of the following restarts the approval cycle, because each one alters either the legal text or the print setup:

  • Any change to wording, including punctuation and net quantity.
  • A different product name, variant or fragrance name.
  • A change of substrate, finish or colour count.
  • A component swap: pump to cap, tube to airless, carton to shrink sleeve.
  • A new barcode, or a barcode moved to a different panel.
  • A change of importer or responsible entity, which changes the address block.

Treating a wording change as a typo fix is the single most expensive habit in packaging. The plate or digital setup is already committed at that point, and the cost of the change is real whether or not it is charged back.

Proof rounds and what each one shows

A soft proof is a PDF and shows layout, text and dimensions. A hard proof is a physical print and shows colour on the chosen substrate. A press proof is taken off the production run and shows what the line actually produces. Approve layout at soft proof, colour at hard proof, and treat the press proof as the reference sample for the batch.

Sign off on a screen and you are approving a light-emitting display, not ink on material. Two monitors showing the same file will not agree, and neither will match the printed result.

Who holds the print-ready file

Ownership matters at reorder, not at first order. Establish before the first run whether the brand receives the layered artwork, the fonts used, and the dieline, or only a flattened PDF. A flattened file is enough to reprint with the same supplier and not enough to move supplier, adjust a claim, or add a market-specific address block without commissioning the design again.

Checks before the file leaves the brand side

  • Net quantity on the artwork matches the fill weight in the specification, not the previous product’s weight.
  • Ingredient list order matches the formula version being produced.
  • Barcode scans from a printed proof, not from a screen.
  • Batch and expiry fields have a defined position that the coding equipment can reach.
  • The address block names the entity that is legally responsible in that market.
  • The version number on the file matches the version number in the approval message.

For the elements that must appear at all, see label compliance. For how a physical sample is signed off against that artwork, see sample approval. For trade terms on reprints and preparation windows, see wholesale FAQ.

Where the cost lands

Most suppliers treat errors in approved artwork as the brand’s cost, and errors in print execution as their own. That split only works if approval is documented. Without a versioned file and a named signatory, every reprint becomes a negotiation, and the supplier’s goodwill — not the contract — decides who pays.

Where to look next

If you are handing a print file to a factory for the first time, the order of sign-offs and who owns each one is set out in the private label process.

A FATAZEN example of this in practice: FATAZEN Floral Hand Cream — Tube Format with a Light Scent Profile.

Comments

One response to “Who Owns Packaging Artwork Approval: Brand, Factory or Printer?”

  1. […] A brand, for this purpose, splits into three separate assets: the trademark (a registered right in a name or logo), the artwork (the specific files that go to print), and the customer relationship (who the end buyer thinks they are buying from). A private label order only transfers the first if it says so in writing. The artwork is a separate question, covered on its own in who owns the artwork after approval. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *